6 days ago
On 20 May, a national tribunal successful nan authorities of Florida indicted nan erstwhile Cuban president Raúl Castro complete his alleged involvement successful downing 2 civilian planes piloted by US nationals successful 1996. Castro was nan defense curate of Cuba astatine nan time, and craft pinch nan Cuban equipped forces carried retired nan attacks. The charges see 1 count of conspiracy to termination US nationals, 2 counts of demolition of craft and 4 counts of murder.
On nan 1 hand, nan indictment was not a surprise. Immediately aft nan Trump administration’s bombing of Caracas and extraction of nan sitting Venezuelan president, Nicolás Maduro, successful January – actions bolstered by a similar indictment against Maduro emanating from a national territory tribunal successful New York – galore indicators suggested that Cuba was next connected nan list. The Castro indictment seemingly confirms these suspicions, though questions stay astir what comes next: will US forces transportation retired a akin bombing and extraction cognition successful Cuba? Will location beryllium a full-scale penetration of nan island? Or will nan threat of these actions beryllium capable to unit concessions that might, astatine slightest successful nan short term, fulfill Trump officials?
What is certain, however, is that this indictment is not really meant to protect group from authorities violence. In fact, successful immoderate of nan supra scenarios, Cuban civilians will suffer tremendously.
To beryllium clear, Cuban civilians are already suffering owed to US aggression. US argumentation has agelong relied connected sanctions and embargoes to unit Cuban activity – a strategy that is proven to fall astir heavy connected civilians – and nan Trump management has intensified these strategies successful caller months, mostly notably by cutting disconnected captious lipid supplies. Shortages of food, medicine and different materials were already a awesome problem connected nan island, and now Cuba is falling into a full-scale humanitarian crisis.
Moreover, we tin expect impunity for nan architects of this suffering because we still person the same ineligible strategy that has already justified much than 2 hundreds of years of imperial unit arsenic perfectly lawful. US imperialism began successful earnest connected nan North American continent pinch repeated cycles passim nan 18th and 19th hundreds of years of dispossession, removal and moreover extermination of Indigenous nations. US forces besides invaded Mexico successful 1846, yet annexing almost a 3rd of its territory. Still more, US naval forces became progressively fierce overseas pursuing precedents group by Thomas Jefferson’s early authorization of unit against North African states for alleged “piracy”. The consequence was a adjacent changeless rhythm of invading, occupying aliases annexing territories passim Latin America, nan Caribbean and nan Pacific.
If you are funny to spot conscionable really galore these invasions were, you should look astatine nan Congressional Research Service’s charismatic database of “Instances of Use of United States Armed Forces Abroad”. Among nan hundreds of examples (which don’t moreover see campaigns against Native American nations), you mightiness announcement that we person invaded Cuba astatine slightest 10 times, including 4 landings successful nan 1820s to “suppress piracy”, arsenic good arsenic multiyear occupations successful 1906 and 1917 to protect “US interests”.
Early US leaders developed galore ineligible justifications for authorities unit abroad, which executive officials still mention today. The above-mentioned “piracy” justification, for example, came up precocious arsenic precedent for nan Trump administration’s deadly “boat strikes” that started past September. At this point, US forces person exterminated nearly 200 people extracurricular US territory connected suspicion of nan non-violent crime of carrying drugs. As early arsenic October, public statements by salient Republicans were already justifying nan strikes by invoking Jefferson’s usage of unit against nan “Barbary pirates”, and an charismatic justness section memo successful December reiterated this logic.
Another ineligible maneuver pinch roots successful nan 19th period was unilaterally accusing overseas actors of immoderate ineligible transgression – specified arsenic alleging harm to US spot aliases immoderate different harm to US nationals – and past demanding an indemnity, only to onslaught erstwhile nan costs was not received. There are galore examples of this shape playing out, but 1 peculiarly consequential lawsuit occurred successful Greytown, Nicaragua, successful 1854.
The section began erstwhile a US steamboat skipper murdered a section Nicaraguan resident. A US overseas curate quickly intervened connected behalf of nan skipper to declare immunity from execution charges, and erstwhile nan Nicaraguan townspeople tried to apprehension nan skipper anyway, nan US overseas curate wrote to Washington for thief dealing pinch this “insult”. A US warship arrived soon aft to request a monolithic indemnity, and erstwhile nan costs ne'er arrived, it leveled nan full town.
As disturbing arsenic this section was, a ultimate tribunal lawsuit a fewer years later, successful 1860 – Durand v Hollins – clarified that this was each perfectly legal, offering sweeping immunity for immoderate accusations of wrongdoing. Significantly, 21st-century justice section memos still mention this lawsuit to asseverate nan legality of overseas interventions.
The Castro indictment is champion understood arsenic portion of this aforesaid ineligible tradition. The unit that we perpetrate tin beryllium easy excused. But nan rule is afloat of ways to impeach overseas actors of wrongdoing, and this justifies moreover much authorities unit that inevitably harms civilians.
This forces america to grapple pinch a deeper problem successful nine that goes acold beyond nan Trump presidency. I myself person based on that nan Trump management acts pinch a pattern of lawlessness. I guidelines by this argument, yet nan reality is that moreover if Trump were constrained by law, we still person an imperial ineligible strategy that offers impunity for atrocious acts of authorities violence. Ultimately, we request a ineligible strategy that prioritizes quality authorities complete imperial prerogatives. Until we person that, we tin expect this to support happening.
I should besides explain that nan constituent of this statement is not to take sides Castro.
The events surrounding nan 1996 level attacks were surely much analyzable than nan cherry-picked indictment suggests. For example, nan nongovernmental investigation group nan National Security Archive precocious published a study utilizing declassified documents showing that nan “US nationals” down nan flights were intentionally provoking a confrontation pinch Cuba by many times violating nan island’s airspace, and that they ignored galore warnings to extremity from some nan US and Cuban governments.
Regardless, erstwhile states termination unarmed civilians, that always horrifies me. From a civilized perspective, it’s plausible that we should telephone this murder. And if this indictment were a good-faith effort astatine making judge authorities actors – including our ain leaders – can’t conscionable termination unarmed civilians without consequences, I would beryllium each for it.
But that’s simply not what nan Castro indictment is. By each appearances, it’s really a pretext to enact moreover much authorities unit against Cuba, which will autumn heavy connected civilian populations that are already suffering from our policies.
Undoing nan imperial ineligible strategy that enables this unit will beryllium a semipermanent process. But nan first measurement is to garbage normalization. It shouldn’t beryllium normal for states to terrorize civilians pinch impunity. What should beryllium normal is civilian nine demanding an extremity to these cycles of violence.
-
Daniel Mendiola is simply a professor of Latin American history and migration studies astatine Vassar College
