The protesters showing up every week to shut down ‘Alligator Alcatraz’: ‘We will end this’

Trending 5 months ago

They travel connected buses, successful cars and RVs. Some thrust connected motorcycles. Every Sunday afternoon, convoys of protesters from each complete Florida, and others from retired of state, descend connected nan notorious “Alligator Alcatraz” migration jailhouse successful nan Everglades to guidelines vigil for those held inside.

It is simply a ritual that began successful August, a period aft nan opening of nan distant detention campy celebrated by Donald Trump for its harsh conditions, and hailed by Florida’s Republican governor, Ron DeSantis, arsenic a exemplary for nan president’s fierce detention and deportation agenda.

The unfastened aerial vigils continued, and grew successful size, done nan sadistic power and torrential rains of nan southbound Florida summer. They endured done a national judge’s bid successful August that “Alligator Alcatraz” should close, and a subsequent reversal by an appeals court; nan protesters’ voices grew louder astatine alleged human authorities abuses and violence inflicted connected detainees.

Over nan vacation season, thousands much group are expected to subordinate nan protests. The Guardian said to respective group astatine nan bosom of nan vigils:

The daughter

Arianne Betancourt’s Cuban-born begetter Justo, 54, was detained during a regular migration check-in assignment successful October and swiftly transported to “Alligator Alcatraz”. He is diabetic, she says, and has been denied his twice-daily insulin injections.

“They conscionable told him he tin get it successful Mexico,” said Betancourt, who recovered spot astatine nan vigils supporting different families pinch loved ones who are incarcerated.

“I’ve met Roxana, her hubby is detained, she has a baby; Michelle, her begetter is detained, and she was location pinch her daughter, who’s 14 aliases 15; there’s Jeffrey, whose fellow was detained. We’re each emotion nan aforesaid way. There’s nary options, nary owed process, nary existent ineligible process, thing you tin appeal, thing you tin fight. So if there’s thing I learn, immoderate resources aliases anything, I’m conscionable sharing it pinch nan different families, because astatine nan extremity of nan time we’re each going done nan aforesaid thing.”

a female speaks into a microphone adjacent to group holding a banner that sounds ‘due process for all’
Arianne Betancourt speaks astatine a vigil connected 16 November 2025. Photograph: Philip Cardella

The oldest of 3 siblings, each US citizens, Betancourt says she is angry astatine what she sees arsenic nan unconstitutional curen of her father, who came to nan state connected a humanitarian parole programme from Panama erstwhile he was a teenager. He served probation for a criminal conspiracy complaint respective years ago, she said, and reported regularly to migration authorities earlier his detention.

He tries his champion not to outcry connected nan uncommon occasions they tin speak by telephone, she said, noting she fears he will abruptly disappear.

“When I talked to him this week he was like, ‘Listen, you know, they’re not giving group tribunal dates, they’re not opinionated earlier a judge. They’re pulling them retired of their cells astatine night, putting them connected a level and sending them to Mexico, sloppy of wherever they’re from,’” she said.

“I’m nan oldest one, truthful I person to beryllium like, ‘OK, hey, you know, everything’s gonna beryllium OK. I’m gonna fig this out.’ But nan truth is I don’t cognize really I’m gonna fig this out.”

The pastor

As pastor of nan Allendale United Methodist religion successful St Petersburg, Andy Oliver has ne'er been acrophobic of diving into governmental issues. The curen of detainees astatine “Alligator Alcatraz”, he said, compelled him to shape a autobus to be nan vigils, and he was encouraged that different locals joined his parishioners to make their voices heard.

“We filled up nan autobus and had to rent a mates much vehicles. We had truthful galore group wanting to beryllium there,” he said.

Oliver sees parallels astatine nan migration jailhouse pinch nan belief stories he preaches.

“In nan Christmas story, nan personification who came to denote Jesus’s presence was his relative John nan Baptist, and he was beautiful quickly thrown successful jailhouse for calling for liberation,” he said.

“Jesus came to bring liberation to people. We person group that are physically being detained moreover beyond nan scope of what nan rule allows, families are being separated, harms are being done. Jesus was calved arsenic a refugee. He spent astir of his ministry pinch group connected nan margins. I deliberation that’s wherever Jesus would be, he’d beryllium calling for these prisons to beryllium emptied.”

Oliver said nan diverseness of nan vigil crowd was notable, and that it was “powerful” to stock nan acquisition pinch group of different faiths.

“I’ve ever been touched by nan family members who show up. Many of them are putting themselves astatine risk,” he said.

“Sometimes group wrong nan jailhouse person called out, truthful we put that connected nan speaker and perceive to prisoners’ experiences of getting acold nutrient pinch worms successful it, inadequate showers, each nan horrible conditions of nan place.

“And conscionable nan travel itself … for galore of america it takes respective hours to get there, and you do a batch of reflection location and back. It’s a agelong thrust and it’s inconvenient, but besides you’re driving backmost to your furniture astatine night, to your family.

“These group person been plucked retired from immoderate life they had into hell.”

The subject veteran

John Reynolds was a US service intelligence master serving successful Vietnam erstwhile he knowledgeable nan first pangs of discomfort astatine really his state treated marginalized populations. Decades later, Reynolds, 81, looks astatine “Alligator Alcatraz” and questions what has changed.

“We person these ICE thugs who person been paid bonuses of $50,000 to return personification disconnected a parkland bench, to apprehension personification successful a religion parking batch that happens to beryllium brown. That’s nan target,” he said.

“I spot group that person served successful nan military, Hispanic, Black, women … and contempt each nan advancement made complete nan years, each of nan efforts, each of nan sacrifices to return america to a amended level of surviving together and appreciating what we have, we person a regime, a group successful powerfulness that are perfectly racist and bigoted.

“The measurement this migrant organization is being tortured, and it’s conscionable beyond thing I’ve ever seen.”

Reynolds ventures crossed nan Everglades each Sunday from his location successful Naples to be nan vigils, which he said he sees arsenic a mini portion of nan protestation movement. “The group present are very good informed of what’s going on,” he said.

“The much nan wide media exposes nan inhumanity, nan injustice, and nan deficiency of owed process, that will beryllium nan acquisition instrumentality to return america further. It’s getting people’s attention, they’re opening to spot much and much examples of injustice, and it’s nan benignant of injustice that they’re not comfortable with.”

An service profession followed by galore years arsenic a schoolteacher, Reynolds says, gave him an appreciation of nan good, but now besides nan bad things he sees astatine “Alligator Alcatraz” and elsewhere.

“It was a awesome experience, a awesome situation and a awesome experience, but to spot really nan state could rotation down those paths again, dishonesty to nan American group again, person this nonaccomplishment of life, walk money again connected [repressing] civilian populations,” he said.

“What was affirmative that came of that? That’s why I told myself I’ve sewage to do thing astir this.”

The civilian authorities activist

Lois Cohen has seen a batch successful a life of civilian authorities activism. The 91-year-old lived done nan assassination of Martin Luther King Jr, bombs astatine Black churches, nan 1965 Bloody Sunday attacks connected protesters successful Selma, Alabama, and nan 1964 Civil Rights Act.

Nothing she has knowledgeable has angered her arsenic overmuch arsenic nan alleged curen of detainees wrong “Alligator Alcatraz”. “Other than nan Holocaust, I can’t ideate this immoderate worse. It’s unbelievable,” she said.

“People support saying, ‘Well, nan Lord will provide, aliases God will.’ I’d emotion to cognize wherever he is, because he’s forgotten astir nan Everglades.”

Cohen said she marched successful precocious schoolhouse protests successful nan 1940s, nan commencement of a lifelong dedication to governmental activism she said still burns powerfully wrong her. She has been astatine “Alligator Alcatraz” each weekend.

“I tin truthful easy constitute a check, anyone tin constitute a check, but that doesn’t get you involved. To spot it, and consciousness it, and emotionally beryllium truthful distressed by it that it changes your full cognition astir life,” she said.

“Because you can’t ideate group being treated for illustration dogs, and kept successful cages for illustration dogs. And erstwhile you’re location it is an highly emotional, gut-wrenching experience.”

Cohen, however, takes comfortableness from nan group she meets astatine nan vigils, and nan connection they deliver. “It is simply a emotion of companionship, and that location are group successful this world who still care, because successful my mundane life I spot excessively galore that don’t,” he said.

“It’s not right. I don’t want to beryllium friends pinch them immoderate more. I want to debar them.”

She said not capable group were alert that nan jailhouse quickly ramped backmost up to afloat cognition aft an appeals tribunal decision successful September, which is why she believes publicity for nan vigils is crucial.

“People don’t cognize astir it. I’ve talked to group and they say, ‘What are you talking about?’ They’re still nether nan presumption that it was closed by nan judge successful Miami,” she said.

The organizer

The maturation of nan play “Alligator Alcatraz” vigils from a fistful of group successful August to a regular gathering of hundreds tin beryllium attributed successful ample portion to Noelle Damico, head of societal justness astatine the Workers Circle.

Her decades of acquisition successful grassroots activism helped propulsion together a divers confederation of religion groups, trades union, veterans, Native American tribes, different defense groups and individuals that show up each Sunday successful nan Everglades, and astatine “freedom vigils” astatine migration detention accommodation astir nan country.

“One of nan astir rewarding parts of this ongoing guidance is that group are uncovering 1 another. They’re breaking their isolation. They’re coming retired from their homes and their neighborhoods, and they’re saying, ‘I’m not unsocial successful reasoning this is wrong, and I’m not unsocial successful wanting to do thing astir it,’” Damico said.

“It’s truthful uplifting to spot group whose paths mightiness not different person crossed, agreed successful shared purpose, successful a belief successful our communal humanity, and a refusal to fto nan Trump administration resistance america further into nan depths of despair.”

two women outcry adjacent to each other
Noelle Damico and Arianne Betancourt astatine a vigil connected 8 November 2025. Photograph: Philip Cardella

Damico said she was already filling buses for nan adjacent 2 weekends. “People are still successful detention, separated wrongfully from their loved ones,” she said. “How tin we not beryllium retired location successful nan tone of nan holidays to proclaim a connection of emotion and justness and hope?”

The closure of nan jailhouse was coming, she said.

“It’s not a matter of if ‘Alligator Alcatraz’ and nan remainder of nan sprawling, sadistic detention web will 1 time unopen down, it’s a matter of when. And erstwhile is up to us,” she said.

“Thousands of people, galore who person ne'er publically protested anything, are coming disconnected nan sidelines to peacefully request an extremity to these violent, vicious abductions, torture, detention, and disappearances, and that is what will find nan timeline.

“It’s not up to Donald Trump. It’s not up to [White House argumentation adviser] Stephen Miller. It’s not up to [homeland information secretary] Kristi Noem. It’s up to us. And we will extremity this.”

More
Source theguardian.com
theguardian.com