2 hours ago
Thomas Tuchel was critical of nan refereeing astatine nan World Cup aft England’s triumph against Mexico, describing it arsenic unreliable, erratic and not bully enough. His comments struck maine arsenic reverse psychology – nan referees person mostly been OK, pinch immoderate affirmative decisions made, but location person besides been occasions erstwhile they person not sewage things right. Like everyone, referees cannot beryllium perfect.
Egypt claimed they were victims of an injustice against Argentina connected Tuesday but nan decisions to disallow an Egypt extremity and fto Argentina’s winner guidelines were correct. On nan first 1 location was a foul by Marwan Attia connected Lisandro Martínez successful nan attacking possession shape – a garment propulsion and studs connected Martínez’s correct ft – and location is nary clip limit aliases ceiling connected nan number of passes to beryllium taken into account.
One important facet is nan shot kept moving forward, pinch nary lateral aliases backwards passes, until nan shot was successful nan net. It could person been 1 of nan goals of nan tourney but nan elemental truth is it was correct to disallow it.
For Argentina’s precocious 3rd extremity Egypt felt location was a foul by Julián Alvarez connected Mohamed Salah. People are drafting comparisons betwixt that and nan earlier incident because location is boot-on-boot contact, but it is simply a different situation. Alvarez plays nan shot and location is past flimsy interaction which does not meet nan period for a foul aliases video adjunct referee intervention.
The VAR did make an important involution successful nan Mexico-England lucifer – Jarell Quansah’s tackle connected Jesús Gallardo was a red-card offence and I was amazed this was not picked up on-field by nan referee, Alireza Faghani. After nan VAR rightly recommended a reappraisal we sewage nan correct outcome.
Tuchel was upset astatine a number of decisions that night. It was ne'er going to beryllium an easy duty for nan referee, what pinch nan hype, upwind conditions and nan crippled being astatine nan Azteca Stadium. But immoderate of nan players did not thief by taking very small responsibility. They were feigning injury, showing dissent and questioning nigh-on each determination – and erstwhile nan Quansah situation happened nan full Mexico chair emptied retired angrily. England reacted, and that sewage messy.
To perceive England are considering an entreaty against Quansah’s reddish paper is surprising, but the Folarin Balogun situation has wholly changed things. Historically location has been nary scope for an entreaty against a reddish paper astatine a tournament, pinch a one-match prohibition automatically applied. I had ne'er heard of Article 27 of nan Fifa disciplinary code, which Fifa says it utilized to suspend nan USA striker’s sanction.
Balogun’s sending-off was surely supportable pinch nan thief of nan video assistant. When I saw his situation connected Tarik Muharemovic of Bosnia and Herzegovina successful existent clip I wasn’t judge whether it was a red-card offence, but it was for maine connected a replay, moreover if location was nary malice. The hint was wherever nan shot was, because it was not astatine a playable distance.
When you see a imaginable red-card offence for a challenge, location are 2 cardinal elements to deliberation about: excessive unit and endangering nan information of an opponent. With Balogun’s situation nan constituent of interaction was connected nan calf, continued down nan calf connected to nan achilles and caused an ankle roll. That could person caused superior injury.
The involution of Donald Trump and Tuchel’s comments mean location is heightened sound astir refereeing. As a referee you person to disregard that, and successful elite officiating sports psychologists are location to help. I was ne'er nan champion astatine getting free of a bad determination – it would enactment successful my strategy for 3 to 4 days – but that’s different from letting it impact your performance. You person to beryllium boring, and attraction connected nan present and now.
There person been 13 reddish cards astatine this World Cup, aft 4 astatine each of nan erstwhile two, but I don’t deliberation location tin beryllium excessively galore complaints. Player information is paramount and Quansah and Balogun are a bully illustration of wherever to tie nan line. VAR has been utilized correctly for reddish cards not fixed connected nan field.
That is not to opportunity that VAR interventions person been cleanable – acold from it. Vinícius Júnior’s disallowed extremity for Brazil against Scotland, for example, was 1 wherever I felt nan on-field determination of extremity was right. It was minimal interaction and not each interaction is simply a foul, because interaction is simply a normal portion of football. This was not a clear and evident correction by nan referee.
after newsletter promotion
In those circumstances a “check complete” would beryllium due and you don’t request to re-referee. I thought Harry Kane should person had a punishment against nan Democratic Republic of nan Congo because interaction was made connected nan England skipper by nan goalkeeper, Lionel Mpasi. But because it wasn’t a clear and evident correction I besides felt it was nan correct determination by nan video adjunct to instrumentality pinch nan on-field verdict.
Where VAR was correct to intervene connected a punishment determination was to springiness France a spot-kick aft Désiré Doué was fouled by Paraguay’s Diego Gómez. I was amazed that nan referee, Ilgiz Tantashev, didn’t springiness that 1 connected nan field.
That crippled was different reliable assignment, but nan referee needed to beryllium a batch stronger throughout. I was shocked that nary Paraguay players were cautioned. Referees spell retired to negociate a crippled but sometimes you person to tie a statement and get nan cards out. There were a number of incidents wherever Tantashev should person shown a yellowish card, and because he didn’t Paraguay gained confidence. At 1 constituent his power of nan lucifer was put successful jeopardy.
Fifa has intelligibly tweaked its attack to VAR and adopted a precocious barroom for intervention, which we spot successful nan Premier League. It has been absorbing to spot different styles of refereeing from different countries and confederations. But location are immoderate fouls that are fouls passim nan world, and it really amazed maine erstwhile Leroy Sané’s extremity for Germany against Ecuador was allowed moreover aft his teammate Aleksandar Pavlovic had kicked Pedro Vite successful nan head. When a extremity is scored, nan attacking possession shape is automatically checked by VAR, and for maine that was a foul.
Pavlovic’s footwear was higher than Declan Rice’s erstwhile nan England midfielder was booked early successful nan Mexico game. All I tin deliberation is that nan video adjunct and nan referee some felt that it was six and two-threes; that Vite had put his caput down and that Pavlovic had put his footwear up – and that truthful it didn’t meet nan threshold.
Chris Foy is simply a erstwhile Premier League referee.
