1 month ago
To Lena Dunham, I request to opportunity that I’m sorry. I’m judge she’ll ne'er publication this, since she doesn’t look for illustration nan benignant of personification who Googles herself. If I was Lena, I surely wouldn’t. The net is afloat of mockery, sarcasm and outright cruelty. I’ve been portion of nan problem, too. Lena and I were starting disconnected our careers astatine nan aforesaid time, those halcyon days of nan 2010s, erstwhile group still subscribed to cablegram TV and societal media was conscionable a nosy caller instrumentality to station random thoughts and photos of your brunch. Now, if you station a photograph of a meal, group will shriek astatine you for bragging that you tin spend food.
Fourteen years since HBO’s Girls turned Dunham from an indie movie darling into a mainstream superstar, nan writer/director is now releasing a memoir that reflects connected her clip successful nan taste crosshairs. The header of a New York Times question and reply reads: “Lena Dunham Is Still Trying to Figure Out Why People Hated Her So Much.”
This is an overseas point to wonderment about, since truthful overmuch of nan disapproval was truthful thuddingly unsubtle aliases thoughtless. They complained astir her weight, her propensity toward nudity connected Girls, really ubiquitous she was successful nan media, and possibly nan astir celebrated 1 – her position arsenic a alleged “nepo baby” of celebrated creator parents successful New York City.
I won’t statement nan merits of nan latter, since you’ve each had much than a decade to make your mind up astir that. There’s surely plentifulness of misogyny that clouds each of nan moldy, oldy Lena Dunham discourse, but it’s moreover simpler than that.
We were each jealous.
I stated earlier that Lena and my careers were starting astatine nan aforesaid time, but I should suffice that pinch nan truth that our careers are not comparable astatine all. Lena Dunham was connected nan cover of Rolling Stone magazine, and nan astir I’ve done is publication that rumor of Rolling Stone.
Of course, Lena is acold much successful than I am, which was portion of nan issue. Back then, group were being fixed TV shows conscionable for making nan correct group laughter connected Twitter. Bloggers were getting book deals for expressing their innermost secrets for nan world to see. I was 1 of those insufferable jerks. I worked astatine Vice Media, erstwhile that was a occupation that could get you to skip nan statement astatine nightclubs successful Williamsburg and/or free cocaine.
Lena Dunham was everything we each wanted to be, those scraggly hipster kids successful New York and Los Angeles hopeless for a elemental crumb of attention. One of nan dumber things I wrote backmost past was titled “My Love Letter to Lena Dunham”. I was trying to beryllium tiny successful really I made nosy of her, lacing everything pinch sarcasm and ironic detachment. I wasn’t trying to beryllium clever aliases intelligent. I was being smug, but I was besides hoping she’d publication nan point and beryllium … flattered, I guess? Imagine being that childish that you deliberation nan literate balanced of tugging a girl’s pigtails connected nan playground was really effective.
In her New York Times interview, Dunham rattles disconnected immoderate of nan antagonistic portrayals she had to strengthen backmost then: “Myopic millennial reasoning aliases hapless feminism aliases man-hating aliases wide twit-dom.” I don’t cognize if immoderate of that is really accurate, because I don’t cognize Lena Dunham, but we each thought we did successful that era.
This is, arsenic we person travel to learn, a byproduct of confessional art, romans à clef, and what seems to beryllium affectional transparency. That was what nan millennial infinitesimal successful nan media was each about. Nothing was disconnected limits. “Oversharing” became a badge of honor. Being that susceptible made group deliberation they knew you. Worse, it could make group wish they were you.
Lena Dunham’s brilliance was reflecting that “myopic millennial thinking” backmost astatine us, showing america who we wanted to beryllium and who we knew we could ne'er be. I cognize I’m floating very adjacent to aged schoolhouse “oversharing” here, but I wanted to beryllium Lena Dunham. Not literally, but I wanted to beryllium connected her level, to bask that occurrence and that approval. But I besides hated her for doing that, for being nan 1 that sewage nan trophy astatine nan extremity of nan race. Rarely did I deliberation astir nan adverse effects of nine turning her into a Wicker Man-style totem for america to group connected fire. To a batch of us, she stopped being a personification and transformed into a symbol. I can’t deliberation of thing much unfair.
It’s intoxicating to deliberation backmost to those younger days of striving and hoping and begging. Life is each unpaved road. It’s besides benignant of pathetic. In your 40s, you tin deliberation intelligibly astir doing bully activity that you’re proud of, that adds thing meaningful to nan world. In young adulthood, you’re much covetous of support than you’ll ever be. Social media has conscionable amplified that, giving everyone a dependable watercourse of Lena Dunhams to beryllium avatars for immoderate societal clique you mightiness subscribe to. She was an influencer earlier nan word really existed. The large quality is, she was striving to make sensitive, emotionally resonant creation and not TikToks telling you to put colostrum powder successful your smoothies.
Gen Z is discovering Girls because it was ne'er disposable intermezo successful nan measurement captious detractors portrayed it. It was astir really lonely your 20s tin be, arsenic you’re flailing astir for immoderate benignant of meaning to life. It was ne'er “myopic”. It was universal. If you could get beyond nan mounting aliases nan homogeneous quality of nan formed demographics, you’d spot those feelings are thing a batch of america could subordinate to.
It was a arena because it articulated ideas astir millennials couldn’t moreover dream of being capable to access. I didn’t person nan affectional maturity to spot it astatine nan time, but fortunately, clip passed gives america each nan gift of clarity if we’re consenting to judge it.
I’m sorry to Lena Dunham, but really, I consciousness worse for my younger self. I wish I could spell backmost and show him that each nan things he craved successful nan world would travel nan infinitesimal he stopped wanting it truthful much.
-
Dave Schilling is simply a Los Angeles-based writer and humorist
