‘Counter to the message of Jesus’: progressive Christians stake a claim to their religion amid Trump-pope feud

Trending 1 month ago

The Trump management has agelong tried to wrap itself successful Christianity, pinch Pete Hegseth, nan defense secretary, invoking warfare “in nan mighty and powerful sanction of Jesus Christ”. Trump moreover precocious posted an AI image of himself as a Christ-like fig (later claiming he thought it was a doctor) and streamed himself reference nan Bible.

But successful reality, religion leaders person been immoderate of nan loudest and astir accordant voices organizing against nan administration’s policies.

Since nan first clip Trump was successful office, Christian and Catholic groups person protested nan militarization of ICE successful American communities, provided beingness shelter to migrants, hosted vigils and coordinated communal aid. They are outraged by nan management waging warfare successful nan sanction of Christianity and are mobilizing “as an look of their faith”, said Rev Dr Liz Theoharis, laminitis and executive head of nan Kairos Center for Religions, Rights and Social Justice.

According to Theoharis and others heralding nan efforts of progressive and societal justice-motivated Christians, much group are joining them. They want to liking a declare to a type of Christianity that’s successful guidance to Trump’s and Hegseth’s.

“One of nan things that was beautiful stunning and beautiful clear from nan very opening of this Trump management is really quiet group are to perceive religion voices and to spot religion leaders pushing backmost against this heretical theology and nan weaponization of faith,” said Theoharis. “People are demanding some – to push backmost against this horrible theology and to unrecorded their religion successful nan nationalist square.”

In nan 2nd Trump administration, faith-based guidance has been possibly astir visible successful protecting immigrants.

In nan fall, imagery of clergy and religion leaders thrown to nan ground and handcuffed while protesting astatine a detention halfway extracurricular Chicago made world headlines. During nan January “economic blackout” organized by residents of Twin Cities residents, 99 religion leaders from crossed nan state were arrested astatine nan Minneapolis airdrome while protesting ICE operations. After Trump ended migration enforcement protections for places of worship, Christian, Jewish, Sikh and different religion denominations, representing thousands of churches, sued nan administration.

Christian leaders are besides hosting continuing events successful their section communities, specified arsenic Good Friday marches to ICE detention facilities. In El Paso, Texas, 2 Scalabrinians Sisters, Leticia Gutiérrez Valderrama and Elisete Signor, coordinate a migrant accompaniment programme that has supported complete 1,000 group successful migration tribunal and much than 300 successful ICE detention. They are besides undertaking symbolic efforts of solidarity: in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, Catholic Workers made themselves wearable “ankle monitors” successful support of section migrants successful an ICE “alternatives to detention” program.

A leader receives aesculapian attraction aft being capsicum sprayed.
A leader receives aesculapian attraction aft being capsicum sprayed by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officers during a protestation successful Broadview, Illinois, connected 19 September 2025. Photograph: Octavio Jones/AFP/Getty Images

Many of these traditions are decades, if not centuries, old. Just look to nan 1960s civilian authorities movement, led successful portion by Black Christians – from Dr Martin Luther King Jr to Bayard Rustin.

“Christians that are willing successful societal justness now and want to face nan Trump management are not inventing thing novel,” said Jonny Rashid, a pastor pinch West Philadelphia Mennonite Fellowship and a nationalist organizer pinch Mennonite Action. “Christians person been navigating against injustice for a agelong clip … we guidelines connected their shoulders.”

Dorothy Day, co-founder of nan Catholic Worker activity successful 1932, was arrested dozens of times protesting against warfare and marching pinch farmworkers. The Berrigan brothers – 2 Catholic priests federally convicted arsenic portion of nan Catonsville Nine, who burned astir 400 draught cards successful 1968 amid nan Vietnam warfare – later helped motorboat nan Plowshares, an anti-war Christian activity that damaged atomic weapons successful factories and led to arrests and jailhouse time.

Over nan past 2 centuries, houses of believe person provided shelter – from their domiciled successful nan Underground Railroad to those resisting nan Vietnam warfare draft. The first sanctuary city was established successful Berkeley, California, successful 1971, aft an organizing effort by section churches to protect draught dodgers. The sanctuary movement later kicked up successful nan 1980s erstwhile US proxy wars successful Central America led to a situation for undocumented migrants seeking asylum and churches took them in.

Generations of organizers person been guided by nan 20th-century emergence of Black liberation theology, Latin American liberation theology and Catholic societal teaching – traditions that grant nan basal dignity of quality life and speak retired against warfare and successful favour of a societal information net.

Amid repeated cuts to societal services, churches person provided basal needs done nutrient kitchens, houses of hospitality and communal aid. In January, Minnesota religion Dios Habla Hoy, nether pastor Sergio Amezcua, delivered much than 14,000 boxes of groceries to migrants sheltering successful their homes from ICE.

Traveling nan state and witnessing organization uprisings against ICE successful nan past fewer months, Theoharis said: “The existent heroes and heroines, nan existent saints of this world, are emerging. There’s really beautiful organizing happening correct now, and I want nan world to cognize astir it.”

Reclaiming Christianity from nan right

Faith-based organizing has besides called for an extremity to war.

Faith leaders who person held “Moral Monday” actions for years – marching to telephone for backing for nan mediocre and marginalized and distant from warfare – rallied outside nan White House past period against nan warfare connected Iran. In mid-April, yet much religion groups held a “pray-in” for nonviolence successful DC, including nan Kairos Center, Catholic Workers, Mennonite Action DMV and Churches for Middle East Peace.

Other iterations of their organizing are needfully interpersonal. The Dorothea Project, whose sanction honors Dorothy Day and Sister Thea Bowman – nan only Black female successful her convent astatine nan clip and who is credited pinch helping to desegregate nan American Catholic religion – was formed past spring. The women-led group organizes Catholic laywomen against injustice by hosting dream circles, sharing acquisition resources astir Catholic societal school to unit religion leaders to condemn ICE. It besides creates scripts to telephone and constitute Vance, who is Catholic, to extremity nan warfare successful Iran.

“We do this activity collectively,” said Chrissy Kirchhoefer, a Catholic Worker, “but our mini actions really tin person a large impact.”

This weekend, Kirchhoefer is protesting pinch chap Catholic Workers astatine a atomic weapons part-making mill successful Kansas City, Missouri. Her Catholic Worker location is besides hosting a vigil complete nan warfare successful Iran.

Multiple religion leaders told nan Guardian they understand why group whitethorn not subordinate progressive organizing pinch Christianity. Rashid pointed to hundreds of years of Christianity utilized arsenic a instrumentality of empire and repression, from manifest destiny and racialized chattel slavery to backing nan autumn of Roe v Wade. Communities impacted by those legacies, for illustration LGBTQ+ people, whitethorn not consciousness comfortable joining them – though they excessively person predecessors successful Christians specified arsenic Episcopal leader Pauli Murray.

While nan correct has organized immoderate Christian denominations into a powerful voting bloc and Christian nationalism has grown in caller years, Rashid argues that it is not existent Christianity: “Christian nationalism is fascism and authoritarianism dressed up pinch Christian symbolism. It is simply a racist, xenophobic, authoritarian, fascistic ideology that gets sold arsenic Christianity.”

A leader holds flowers arsenic equipped riot constabulary guidelines nearby
A leader holds flowers arsenic constabulary face anti-ICE protesters successful Los Angeles, California, connected 10 June 2025. Photograph: Tayfun Coskun/Anadolu via Getty Images

Two-thirds of Americans are either skeptical of aliases against Christian nationalism. And astir of America’s millions of Christians, from various backgrounds and denominations, person ne'er been each successful connected Trump: according to Pew Research polling from February, achromatic Evangelicals “are nan only ample belief group successful which a clear mostly o.k. of Trump’s occupation performance”. Most Americans don’t spot him arsenic belief astatine all, according to recent Pew Research polling.

Even governmental candidates are seeking to reclaim nan communicative that Christianity is not nan spot of Republicans aliases nan right.

James Talarico, a Texas Democratic legislature hopeful, has built his level connected a progressive imagination of Christian faith, saying God is nonbinary connected nan Texas authorities location floor, wherever respective anti-trans measures person passed complete nan past fewer years. The mostly of Christians support LGBTQ+ authorities and abortion access, some of which Talarico has besides utilized Christian rhetoric to support. More clergy are besides moving arsenic pro-social justness candidates while citing their faith – a motion group are calling for an replacement wrong nan governmental sphere.

In consequence to Trump’s and Hegseth’s Christian nationalist rhetoric, Pope Leo XIV wrote this month, “God does not bless immoderate conflict. Anyone who is simply a disciple of Christ, nan Prince of Peace, is ne'er connected nan broadside of those who erstwhile wielded nan beard and coming driblet bombs.”

Of Hegseth’s telephone for “no mercy” for Iran, Kirchhoefer said: “That is simply a radically different predisposition that is truthful antagonistic to nan connection of Jesus – of nonviolence, turning nan different cheek.”

More
Source theguardian.com
theguardian.com