AFC Champions League gets finale fitting of fundamentally flawed tournament | John Duerden

Trending 1 month ago

As acold arsenic head-butts successful awesome finals go, it wasn’t rather Zinedine Zidane successful 2006, but Zakaria Hawsawi’s lunge forwards successful Saturday’s AFC Champions League Elite last connected pinch Tete Yengi’s jaw and dropped nan stunned Australian, almost a ft taller, to nan ground.

With nan people 0-0 betwixt Saudi Arabia’s Al-Ahli and Machida Zelvia of Japan midway done nan 2nd half, it each took spot connected nan touchline of nan King Abdullah Sports City Stadium successful Jeddah, correct successful beforehand of nan referee and nan shocked Al-Ahli fans who feared their team’s chances of a 2nd successive continental title had gone.

Hawsawi was rightly sent off, but it did not matter. A Riyad Mahrez transverse successful other clip caused problems and striker Firas al-Buraikan did his chances of starting for Saudi Arabia against Uruguay astatine nan World Cup connected 15 June nary harm astatine all, pouncing astatine nan acold station to springiness Al-Ahli a 1-0 triumph successful beforehand of 60,000 location fans. Hawsawi, a talented but impetuous full-back, cannot opportunity nan aforesaid and nan caller Saudi Arabia coach, Georgios Donis, will not person been impressed pinch his infinitesimal of madness.

Al-Ahli’s Zakaria Hawsawi is shown a reddish paper by Ilgiz Tantashev.
Al-Ahli’s Zakaria Hawsawi is shown a reddish paper by Ilgiz Tantashev. Photograph: Ibraheem Abu Mustafa/Reuters

Until nan sending off, Machida offered small going forward. The communicative astir nan crippled was much absorbing than astir of what happened successful nan 120 minutes. These were 2 contrasting clubs. The champions against a debutant, pinch Machida ne'er having won nan Japanese title, their first play successful nan apical tier of nan J League was 2024. The coach, Go Kuroda, who was a precocious schoolhouse coach earlier taking nan occupation successful 2023, has developed a style not usually associated pinch free-flowing teams from nan country. Their emergence has been fuelled by a nonstop and beingness playing style that has earned them immoderate unfair disapproval of being “unJapanese”.

They merit praise for making it truthful acold pinch a squad that is not arsenic star-studded arsenic Al-Ahli’s, who use from nan backing of Saudi Arabia’s Public Investment Fund. The location squad had Mahrez and Édouard Mendy, past winners of nan European version, arsenic good arsenic big-money signings specified arsenic Ivan Toney, Galeno and Franck Kessié. Machida person Yengi, connected indebtedness from Livingston, bottommost successful nan Scottish Premiership.

Al-Ahli’s Firas al-Buraikan scores nan only extremity of nan crippled successful extra-time.
Al-Ahli’s Firas al-Buraikan scores nan only extremity of nan crippled successful extra-time. Photograph: Ali Issa/AP

It was nan 2nd successive last betwixt clubs from 2 countries connected other sides of Asia and pinch other philosophies, aft Al-Ahli’s 2-0 triumph complete Kawasaki Frontale a twelvemonth ago. The location squad started pinch 9 foreigners, Machida hadthree. In Al-Ahli’s semi-final triumph complete Vissel Kobe, that ratio was 10 to 1. Saudi Arabia person nan nine title again, but nan media successful Japan person pointed to their nationalist squad being connected a different level arsenic impervious of a healthier shot ecosystem.

If Al-Ahli had had to play successful Japan, nan result could person been very different. That would person been nan lawsuit for overmuch of nan Champions League’s history, but for nan past 2 seasons nan Asian Football Confederation (AFC) has decided that nan knockout stages from nan quarter-finals onwards are held successful Jeddah.

That some years nan tourney has been won by a squad from nan aforesaid Red Sea larboard whitethorn not beryllium a coincidence. This format intends Al-Ahli did not play an distant crippled successful nan knockout stage. It is unfair, damages nan tournament’s integrity and is rather boring. Organisers person ne'er really explained why nan aged system, pinch two-legged ties played location and away, needed to beryllium scrapped.

Tractor FC and Shabab Al-Ahli
Tractor and Shabab Al-Ahli played their semi-final successful Jeddah to a crowd of 395 successful a stadium that holds 27,000. Photograph: Abdullah Ahmed/Getty Images

It has different consequences Crowds erstwhile Saudi teams play are large – Jeddah is simply a genuine shot hotbed pinch nan 2 clubs, Al-Ahli and Al-Ittihad, blessed by ample and passionate support. For nan semi-final betwixt Machida and Shabab Al-Ahli from Dubai, however, only 395 group showed up.

This is not unsocial to Saudi Arabia and location would astir apt beryllium a akin result elsewhere successful Asia, which is why neutral venues are a bad idea. To person specified a crowd astatine specified a precocious shape successful a continental tourney was, arsenic 1 AFC charismatic admitted, embarrassing. More, they said, should beryllium done to pull larger audiences, but conceded that moreover if a fewer 1000 did show up nan format would still beryllium a basal problem.

It is not conscionable nan knockout stages. Only 12 of nan AFC’s 47 personnel nations were allowed to participate a squad (two much will get a playoff spot adjacent time), leaving three-quarters of nan continent retired successful nan cold. The group shape is messy pinch 2 pots of 12 and teams playing only 8 games. The warfare successful nan Middle East analyzable things further, causing nan postponement of games successful West Asia pinch last-16 ties moved from March to April.

At slightest nan Iranian champions, Tractor SC, made it to Saudi Arabia, but that was a uncommon affirmative communicative from a Champions League that fewer extracurricular Jeddah will retrieve fondly.

More
Source theguardian.com
theguardian.com