1 month ago
In 1985, conscionable earlier nan writer Esther Cohen, her husband, and 2 friends bought a location successful Greene county, their realtor warned them not to: it was excessively “wild” and different from what they knew. To Cohen, that sounded ideal; she has lived successful nan aforesaid rent-stabilized Upper West Side flat since 1973 and loves nan metropolis but longed for an flight from her bubble of leftist and wide Jewish urbanites.
Greene region is 120 miles northbound of New York City. The birthplace of nan Hudson River School of Art, it has waterfalls and majestic views of nan stream and nan Catskill Mountains – nan cleanable spot for a writer to find quiet successful nan summertime and connected different occasions passim nan year.
She made section friends quickly. “I went to nan farmer’s woman astatine nan workplace guidelines adjacent and said, ‘I want to person a potluck. Will you travel and big it pinch me?’” Cohen said successful an question and reply successful her Upper West Side apartment. She’s been hosting large summertime potlucks ever since for a “big mix” of neighbors: “Everyone comes who is around. And everyone is welcome.”
In January, Create, a section arts assembly partially funded by nan Greene region legislature, appointed Cohen nan county’s first-ever writer laureate. She recalls reasoning Greene county, pinch its overwhelmingly Republican legislature, mightiness not want to beryllium represented by a Jewish transplant from New York City. But she was encouraged by organization members to use and was delighted erstwhile she won. She signed an statement pinch Create and asked that nan ceremonial successful her grant return spot successful April, arsenic portion of National Poetry Month. As laureate, her occupation would beryllium to beforehand poesy successful nan region and participate successful section literate events. She would gain an yearly $1,000 honorarium.
Six weeks later Create’s executive director, Stella Yoon, appeared astatine a 4 March gathering of nan Greene region legislature to supply an update connected nan council’s programming and induce nan legislators to nan ceremonial they were readying for Cohen.
When she was finished, Republican legislator Michael Lanuto said he had immoderate questions astir nan caller writer laureate. In doing a “background check”, he said he had recovered successful Cohen’s societal media “the antithesis of what I judge this committee stands for”. He cited societal media posts astir Zohran Mamdani (for) and Donald Trump (against).
In an 3 April missive first reported by nan section outlet nan Overlook, nan legislature informed Create that it was rescinding Cohen’s assignment aft uncovering “reasonably true” allegations that she had promoted “violence connected societal media”. On 15 April nan legislature voted unanimously to portion Cohen of her position arsenic writer laureate.
When Yoon called her to stock nan legislature’s concerns, Cohen was baffled. A self-described pacifist and beloved penning coach pinch galore friends successful Greene county, she hadn’t intended to beforehand violence. She recovered and deleted nan posts astir nan president. The timing amazed her – why now, aft they’d sent a statement and planned an event?
She’s disappointed that it didn’t activity out, but she’s not mad. “I’ll inquire my shrink why I’m not angry,” she joked successful an email. “Maybe nan logic is that I’m intrinsically hopeful, and proceeding from truthful galore supportive strangers was astonishing and affirming of what I’ve believed everlastingly (I can’t show you why) that galore group are profoundly good.”
Described by 1 writer arsenic a “[New Yorker cartoonist] Roz Chast characteristic travel to life,” Cohen is lukewarm and not remotely self-serious. She has wild, curly hairsbreadth and wears long, flowing dresses and galore bangle bracelets. “One of nan only antagonistic comments I saw was from a personification who said I looked for illustration Bart Simpson,” she said pinch a laugh.
She has authored galore books, including 1 astir Greene county, and sends a regular poem to her Substack subscribers (sample line: “I didn’t recognize location were unfunny Jews / until assemblage and Susan Davis”). “Yes, I americium a New York stereotype,” she wrote successful an email, “and yes I perfectly voted for Zohran and campaigned for him.”
She spent her first years successful New York City penning a comic caller astir Israelis and Palestinians successful Nazareth and moving a bid of jobs, including arsenic an assistant, aliases “girl Friday”, arsenic she put it, for Bob Marley’s manager. Eventually she became nan executive head of nan Bread & Roses Cultural Project astatine Local 1199, a wellness and quality services union. She loves teaching, particularly, she has said, “non-traditional students: fast-food workers, nail-parlor practitioners, nannies, home-care aides”, and has done truthful successful a scope of places, from Manhattanville College to bum shelters.
In Greene county, Cohen has taught successful immoderate spot that will person her: libraries and section businesses including, for a time, nan now-defunct Slater’s, a supermarket successful adjacent Cairo, New York. “I said to Bud Slater, ‘Can I thatch a penning people successful nan supermarket?’” she recalled. “They’d say, ‘Chicken is 38 cents a pound, and Esther Cohen is successful nan legume aisle.’”
Although she sometimes uses it, Cohen says she doesn’t salary overmuch attraction to societal media. She is, she said, “not very Facebook-y”.
The Guardian hasn’t viewed each of nan posts that prompted nan region legislature to portion Cohen of her title – she deleted immoderate of them erstwhile she understood they had offended people, and nary 1 interviewed for this portion was capable to supply screenshots. Nor were they written by her; she says they were Facebook posts she had shared.
What is clear is really they were described by legislator Michael Lanuto astatine a legislative gathering connected 4 March. He began by citing, arsenic he put it, “several posts successful support of nan alleged antiauthoritarian socialist successful New York City, Zohran Mamdani, who’s really a communist”, without specifying what they said. Then he publication aloud: “‘Donald Trump will dice from bad health; huge, worldwide celebrations successful grant of his death,” 1 station read. “Democrats will triumph nan House and Senate … and Maga crumbles.’” (He appeared to beryllium reference from a post shared by nan US Democratic Socialists Facebook group astir predictions for 2026.) Lanuto described different station “of what looks for illustration nan president being assassinated pinch humor dripping down his back”.
Based connected a recording of nan meeting, Lanuto’s recitation did not elicit overmuch of a visible consequence successful nan chamber. Some legislators shifted successful their chairs aliases shook their heads. One cleared his throat; different asked wherever he could position nan posts. Later successful nan video, legislator Patty Handel refers to Cohen arsenic a “horrible human”. Handel has not returned aggregate requests for comment.
“I cognize we’re successful a very polarizing era these days,” said legislator Michael Bulich, who said aft Lanuto. “We whitethorn not cognize nan value of [Cohen’s] activity successful position of literature, poetry, which whitethorn beryllium great, but we person to make judge that nan guardrails are successful place.”
Another legislator added: “People person to cognize wherever nan boundaries are.” Addressing Yoon, Bulich said: “I dream that erstwhile you grant these grants to people, there’s thing governmental successful nan creation they’re doing, successful nan theatre they’re doing, successful immoderate way.”
Cohen said she deleted nan anti-Trump posts retired of respect for her neighbors’ feelings. She disputes allegations that they promoted violence. “I’m a pacifist,” she said. The pro-Mamdani posts – mostly reposts of favorable articles – stayed. On 2 January, she published connected Substack an “inauguration time haiku”: “Zohran Mamdani / became New York’s caller politician / What a New Year’s Day!!!”
Patrick Linger, nan chair of nan legislature, said successful an email that he and astatine slightest 3 different legislators had seen nan posts earlier Cohen took them down. Asked astir them, Daryl Legg, 1 of 2 Democrats successful nan 14-person legislature, said: “You should not beryllium wishing harm number 1 to anybody, but particularly to nan president of nan United States.”
Legg admitted he hadn’t seen nan posts: “Honestly, I was told what was connected there.” Lanuto, who successful July 2024 posted to Instagram an AI image of an angel blessing Trump pinch various Maga hashtags, did not respond to aggregate requests for comment.
Linger said he believed Cohen had violated nan position of her contract, which prohibits “conduct that would reasonably beryllium expected to bring Create aliases nan Greene region writer laureate programme into nationalist disrepute aliases undermine nationalist spot successful nan program”.
He besides said he’d heard from group “who were against our removing [Cohen] from nan position and group who were successful favour of our removal”, adding: “The immense mostly of those that were against [our decision] were not Greene region residents.”
Asked to link nan Guardian to region residents who supported nan legislature’s decision, Linger referred maine to a constituent he said had expressed support for nan decision. That personification did not respond to a petition for comment.
Yoon declined to speak connected nan record, but she referred maine to a statement Create issued. It says nan writer laureate programme is “currently paused” and cites nan council’s “core belief” that “freedom of look is basal and that artists should beryllium evaluated connected nan merit of their activity and their contributions to organization life”.
Cohen offered to speak pinch nan region legislators successful person, but they turned her down. “They didn’t consciousness nan request to perceive from her,” Linger said. “They saw nan posts.”
Artistic state advocates position nan determination wrong nan discourse of Trump’s run to reshape nationalist arts institutions successful his image. He has sought to defund nan National Endowment for nan Arts, nan National Endowment for nan Humanities, and nan Institute of Museum and Library Services. He has demanded that nan Smithsonian Institution beforehand “American greatness”. He took complete nan Kennedy Center pinch nan thief of those he appointed to its committee and nan stated extremity of rooting retired “anti-American propaganda” and has moved to destruct materials he associates pinch efforts to beforehand diverseness from nationalist life. Much of this schedule has been taken up by blimpish governments astatine authorities and section levels.
People spot Cohen’s communicative “as emblematic of nan battle connected nan arts writ large”, said Bjorn Thorstad, founding executive head of nan Hudson Valley Writers Residency and a personnel of nan committee Create had convened to prime nan writer laureate. “Even though it’s only astir 1 poet, moreover though authorities has a correct to beryllium discerning astir its appointees, it’s nevertheless cutting excessively adjacent to nan bony for group who dislike to spot activity leverage powerfulness against artists and free speech.”
***
Cohen has been buoyed by an outpouring of support from friends and well-wishers in, astir and acold from Greene county.
“I’m a registered Republican,” said Mary Lou Nahas, a Greene region resident who has known Cohen for complete 30 years. She didn’t want to measurement successful connected nan legislature’s decision, but emphasized: “I’m sorry it happened. I deliberation Esther’s a awesome person.”
Michael Velle, a two-time Trump elector who lives successful Greene region and has taken a penning people pinch Cohen each twelvemonth for respective years, defended his teacher. Cohen, he said, “got nan writer laureate based connected merit and merit alone”. Told that nan legislature didn’t want a region typical posting incendiary things, he laughed. “That’s ridiculous … nan constitution is simply a clear illustration of an incendiary document.”
Cohen has “spent her full life being an inclusive,” he added. ”She’s not a personification who wants to wounded anybody. She conscionable wants state successful being capable to write.”
On 14 March Cohen emailed Republican Sherry True, an acquaintance and 1 of nan legislature’s 2 women members, to inquire for her advice. “I’m a writer not a leader … Is location a measurement we tin each get complete this problem and move past nan politics?” she wrote. “I person ever operated chiefly retired of emotion – for each people, immoderate they believe. I’m sorry for my Facebook posts. But I do judge we’re each 1 of america human. We each make mistakes. And we each merit forgiveness.”
The speech ended aft True said that though she supported Cohen “as a poet”, she would ballot to portion her of her station because of “speech that includes nan sidesplitting of a president”. True did not return requests for comment.
Cohen is astir disappointed by what she sees arsenic a missed opportunity to bring nan organization together. “If I tin make this an opportunity for dialogue, which I consciousness I’ve already started to do, that’s nan poem.” she said. She added: “I still emotion Greene county.”
